Earth stocks


EARTH TIMELINE

11 May 2560: Earth hit the first floor - stock hitting a floor means that their selling price drop to 30 percent of its yesterday ending price. this is not a regular event in trading, a company stock hitting floor means that something went wrong in the company. So this left investors with question.

12 May 2560: Earth hit the second floor - price hitting floor is quite odd but hitting a second time in a consecutive day is super rare. At the time, people were frustrated by the floor and came up with a bunch of theory, later the story came out that their stock gets forced sales by a broker.

7 June 2560  first public clarification that the firm will not be able to repay B/E bonds worth of 40 million baths and state they won’t be able to repay the upcoming each either this is quite a bad sign coming out from the company, if they cannot pay debt like this one, other debt will not be paid.
8 June 2560 SEC demanded further information whether the statement which they made the day before will affect the regular process of the company. Also, on the same day, the stock hit its third floor.

15 June 2560 Earth stated to the public about concerned that SEC asked. The company encountered liquidity problems as they could not borrow money from a financial institute while holding huge debt. Later that day, SET change Earth stock status to SP mark (suspension from trading)


24 July 2560 Earth company file for recovery treatment as they go bankrupt the main reasons of the bankruptcy is they have debt more than asset which is really odd because they have 26000 million baht of incremental debt in a single period which comes from partner and supplier of the firm.

What went wrong with energy earth stock?

As we can see. Variety of event occurred during the time, one to trigger all of the effects have to be floor hitting event that crippled the company severely. The event created a chain reaction from event to event. The cause reflects through many ways such as the company facing liquidity problems right afterward the floor, liquidity problem lead to the first declaration of default in B/E loans. And it goes on until the end of the transaction. The major change point is that the CEO is willing to risk his company and use it as collateral to proceed in another investment, it went sour and it causes the company a whole lot more than the collateral itself. Also, things didn't go their way as well, they can’t finance their loans and supplier lead to more debt and eventually more loan itself, they cannot keep investors trust and faith enough to convince them to buy their bond or stock in the time they need it and lastly, SET shutdown their stock forbid from selling and buying, leaving them no chance to transaction anymore.

What happened to EARTH stock?

At first, the stock price of earth stock fell to the first floor (from about 4 baht to 2.82 bath per share) on 11th May 2560 and the second floor (1.98 bath per share) on the next day but no one the reason of the price fall. The truth is the owners took their own stock to guarantee a few brokers to borrow money to invest in other business, using contracts called “FUTURES”. But the futures have high risk because the leverage will accelerate the money of investors and lose faster than usual. For example, if we use 4 times the leverage, the stock goes down by 25%, it's like we're 100% financially exhausted. That made the brokers set the rules when earth stock went down to a certain level, their stock had to get forced sales at all prices because they fear that the company will be no money to pay when the stock continues to go down again.

Afterward, on 7th June, the company announced the default payment of B/E 40 million bath and state they won’t be able to repay the upcoming each either. On 8th June, earth stock hit to the third floor (1.45 bath per share).On 9th June, earth stock hot to the fourth floor (1.20 bath per share). After earth stock has dived, trading the earth stock is active that made price of earth stock raise up to 1.46 bath per share. Later, the earth stock was marked with H and SP(securities are in the process of being banned for trading).

Causes of the bankruptcy

Starting from the company having the contract of futures for borrowing the money by taking stocks to guarantee as well as the leverage of capital structure (debt>equity). When the company faces business problems that is lack of financial liquidity, it makes the company unable to settle in time. The creditors see default risk increasing. Therefore, the company is forced to sell the stocks for settlement, causing demand for stock falls. Because of the excess supply of stock, prices drop to the 3rd floor and rise beyond expectation lately. This turbulence results in the SEC has to trade halt and suspension. (shareholders cannot convert assets into money) Although trading is suspended, with this price level being much lower that causes a decrease in the market capital, wealth and liquidity of the company decrease. The capital structure (debt>equity) results in the company being unable to settle all remaining debts and leads to be filed of bankruptcy.

Who lost money or likely to lose money

Earth stock suffered a liquidity problem which simply means that they can’t repay their debt, People who bought Earth bonds during the period are the victims. Also, the financial institutes who lend Earth money only to know that they can’t pay them back, Krung Thai bank is their main lender. And lastly, Earth stockholder who got impacted from the floor event and people who believe in Earth company can make a comeback from floor event from time to time, buy the stock with an idea that the price will bounce back, SP status statement is the harshest news for the stockholders as they realized their stock of Earth is worthless now.

What are the responses of SEC? How effective are the SEC's actions?


SEC acts to Earth and any other company is mainly questioning for clarification to their past action and activity physically and accounting such as the suspicious incremental amount in cash flow of the company, SEC will come in and ask where the money comes from and if they don't get good enough answer they will found it out themselves. SEC important actions to earth are the following

8 May 2560: SEC demand information about what will happen to the company from not be able to pay their B/E paper that they stated. This question is to ensure that earth is still working fine after the problem which they aren't, they failed to pay their debt and cannot borrow more to solve liquidity problems. We would not know this kind of information if SEC didn't ask and still have trust in the company

23 May 2560: SEC requested earth to be examined by a special audit on their relevance in unearned income information whether it is legit and require answers in 30 days.

9 Aug 2560: SEC assigned to earth to explain about their incremental 26,000 million baht debt about where it comes from etc. A very important question that needs an answer fast.

SEC in Earth case prove a lot about how important SEC are and stand for and if we didn't have SEC available to precaution the problem, many more casualties gonna be involved in and the problem gonna be more severe.


Reference:

  • สรุปมหากาพย์หุ้น EARTH. (2017, October 13). Retrieved from http://longtunman.com/1483
  • Rassarin. (2017, August 15). จับตา! 16 ส.ค.ดีเดย์ EARTH ต้องชี้แจง กลต.ปมหนี้งอก 2.6 หมื่นล้าน. Retrieved from https://www.brandbuffet.in.th/2017/08/earth-learning-for-investors/
  • EfinanceThai.com. (n.d.). ก.ล.ต.เชือดบอร์ด EARTH ยกแก๊ง เสกหนี้เก๊ 2.6 หมื่นลบ. Retrieved from https://www.efinancethai.com/HotNews/hotnewsmain.aspx?name=SFYwdGkreGo4MW9COXBlUlRHSU14QT09
  • Comapany summary. Retrieved from https://www.set.or.th/set/factsheet.do?symbol=EARTH&ssoPageId=3&language=en&country=US
  • ชำแหละ EARTH สู้ยิบตา สะเทือน "บิ๊กกรุงไทย". (2017, August 12). Retrieved from https://www.prachachat.net/finance/news-21597
  • Importance announcement and news from EARTH Retrieved from https://www.set.or.th/set/companynews.do?symbol=EARTH&ssoPageId=8&language=th&country=TH
  • Stockprice graphic. Retrieved from https://www.kaohoon.com/content/159106



Comments